Tuesday, March 04, 2025

Watson. I Tried.

I wasn't sure after one episode.

I wasn't sure after two episodes.

I was pretty sure after three episodes.

After 10 minutes of episode four, I'm certain.

Medical dramas are rarely my thing.  I enjoyed this year's Brilliant Minds, but that's the first one I've liked at all in a long, long time.  

The much praised House was about as close as I've come to enjoying a medical drama in years and it wore thin after a few episodes for me.  It was a medical take on Sherlock Holmes and even that twist didn't really draw me in.  When I watch a detective procedural, once the who/why/how is revealed, I get a sense of "aha" from the resolution.  In a medical drama, I hardly ever get that because the culprit is rarely anything I can grasp as a layman.

Watson is yet another medical take on the Holmes mythology that just didn't work for me.  I like Morris Chestnut, but the cast around him (except Richie Coster as Shinwell - chef's kiss that guy!) is so painfully "built by writer's room sub-committee" as to be laughable.  Making the sidekick the leader of this band of ridiculous misfits is a risky strategy and in this case...

Sidekicks are sidekicks for a reason.

Moving on.

No comments: